In addition to a more in-depth and informative introduction, I think the book as a whole could have included more scholarly apparatus, including a less sketchy, multi-lingual bibliography, without harming its appeal to a general audience.If Pollard assumes anything about his audience, it is that they are familiar with the European prose essay, which I think leaves some room for doubt especially with respect to the younger generations.
Moreover certain Republican period publications such as Shen Qiwu’s 1932 (The Late Ming xiaopin: twenty masters) exerted an influence on the modern Chinese essay, and these could at least have been mentioned.
The reader who wants to explore the Chinese essay in more detail would have benefited greatly from some guidance as to which anthologies are best, and which exerted the greatest influence.
Because of the infancy of the study of the Chinese essay in English, an anthology like this and its introduction are potentially seminal statements, situating this genre in the field of Chinese cultural studies in general, justifying our interest in it, and pointing the way to avenues of further inquiry.
But if answers the question, Why publish or read such an anthology? Pollard observes that there has not been a general anthology of Chinese essays published since Herbert Giles’ 1884 , so his argument begins from a gap or lack in the representation of a genre.
After detailing in the Preface negative aspects of traditional Chinese culture and literary conventions that explain why premodern Chinese essays do not resemble those of Montaigne and Bacon, Pollard does go on to list what he feels are some of the positive aspects of the Chinese essay in general: “The qualities are on the one hand common to mankind, on the other particular to Chinese literary arts.
The first kind includes the expression of character in the writer, either impressively strong or appealingly weak; the expression of sentiment, usually to commemorate friends and relatives; nostalgia for past times; appeals for justice and compassion; pleasure in diversions.
Yet this general-audience orientation is belied by the inclusion of Chinese characters for authors’ names and titles to works.
Indeed those who would benefit from the Chinese characters (most of the likely audience of this collection) will generally want more bibliographical information, as well as some engagement with scholarship in the field such as Yu-shih Chen’s .
I applaud his insistence that personal taste—an important theme in ancient and modern essays—was his principal guide.
This accounts for his enthusiastic inclusion of essays by Gui Youguang (1506-1571) despite their criticism by the modern essayist Lin Yutang, his exclusion of Lin Yutang’s own essays, and no doubt as well the inclusion of contemporary writer Yu Qiuyu, well-known for his popular, fictionalized imaginings of significant historical moments, over those with strong links to the Republican period essay tradition like Wang Zengqi, Zhang Zhongxing and Ji Xianlin.
Comments Essay About Chinese Culture
Chinese Culture and the Cultural Diversity Research Paper.
Buy 1684-word Research Paper on "Chinese Culture and the Cultural Diversity" ☘ Due to. Pages 3 1103 words Type Essay Bibliography Sources 3.…
Chinese Customs essays
China is a land with unique traditional customs. Through the late early twentieth century China was fairly isolated which hindered cultural diffusion from the rest.…
Nature in Chinese Culture Essay Heilbrunn Timeline of Art.
In no other cultural tradition has nature played a more important role in the arts than in that of China. Since China's earliest dynastic period, real and imagined.…
China in my eyes China Unlimited
What amazes me in the history and culture of China is how Europe announces it the. process with that not only the Chinese culture but the world culture entered in ages of. Your essay “China in my eyes” is well organized, so that every part.…
Chinese Culture Traditions Essay - 549 Words - BrightKite
Read this full essay on Chinese Culture Traditions. The dictionary defines “culture” as “the behavior and beliefs characteristics of a particular social.…
Looking At The Chinese Lifestyle And Norms Essay Example.
Mar 12, 2019. China is the world most populated country with a number of cultures dating back to several. read full Essay Sample for free.…
Selling China COM and Cultural Nationalism a.
As such, it provides a rich context for a discussion of contemporary Chinese cultural nationalism. Historians and students alike can examine nationalism and.…
Chinese Culture Essay Topics
Chinese culture is such a huge topic it can be difficult to know where to begin. This lesson aims to narrow the focus a bit by providing teachers.…
The Chinese Essay MCLC Resource Center - OSU
The Chinese Essay is the first anthology to provide a comprehensive. After detailing in the Preface negative aspects of traditional Chinese culture and literary.…